Inside Big Mistakes: Unpacking Netflix’s Dark Crime-Comedy Thriller

Dying Nonnas, Stolen Jewelry, and Accidental Cartel Entanglements

• The Setup: The story kicks off when directionless siblings Nicky (played by Dan Levy, who is also an openly gay pastor) and Morgan (played by Taylor Ortega) are desperately looking for a parting birthday gift for their grandmother as she reaches death’s door.
• The Catalyst: Morgan impulsively commits a reckless theft, stealing an expensive piece of jewelry that immediately drags the siblings face-first into the brutal, unpredictable world of organized crime.
• The Spiral: Blackmailed into executing dangerous tasks for local criminals, Nicky and Morgan bumble through a escalating series of high-risk assignments while trying desperately to keep their dangerous double lives hidden from their fiercely ambitious mother, Linda (played by a powerhouse Laurie Metcalf), who is concurrently running a high-profile local mayoral campaign.

  

• 

Key Cast & Creative Pedigree

• Dan Levy and Taylor Ortega anchor the series with frantic, chaotic sibling chemistry, playing characters who constantly push each other into worse and worse decision-making loops.
• Laurie Metcalf steals scenes as a woman juggling local political warfare and family dysfunction with zero patience for incompetence.
• Co-Creation: Co-created alongside Rachel Sennott (Shiva Baby, Bottoms), the series leans heavily into sharp, cringe-inducing dialogue and tonal pendulum swings that map out the absurd overlap between low-level crime and suburban politics.

The Verdict